Root Canal vs. Tooth Extraction: Which One Should You Choose?

When you’re dealing with a significantly decayed or infected tooth, your dentist may give you two treatment options: a root canal or a tooth extraction. It’s a common crossroads for many adults, and it can be a tough decision—especially if you’re already in pain or unsure about what each treatment really involves.

Understanding the differences between these procedures is more than just a matter of cost or convenience. These procedures affect the immediate health of your mouth, your future dental function, the look of your smile, and your overall well-being. Each treatment path brings its own set of pros, cons, and long-term implications.

In this blog, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know: what each procedure entails, the benefits and drawbacks, what to expect during recovery, and the potential costs involved. We’ll also answer some of the most frequently asked questions patients have when facing this choice—so you can move forward with clarity and peace of mind.

Need to consult with a dentist? Schedule an appointment today!

What Is a Root Canal Treatment?

Root canal treatment is a common dental procedure designed to save a tooth that has been severely damaged by decay, trauma, or infection. Dentists and endodontists perform over 15 million root canals in the U.S. every year.

When the soft inner tissue of the tooth—known as the tooth pulp—becomes inflamed or infected, it can lead to significant pain, sensitivity, and even abscesses if left untreated. In these cases, a root canal may be the best option to preserve your natural tooth.

During the procedure, a dental professional carefully removes the infected pulp from inside the tooth. The root canals are then cleaned, disinfected, and shaped to eliminate any lingering bacteria. Once the area is sterile, the space is filled and sealed to prevent future infection. In most cases, the treated tooth is then topped with a custom dental crown to restore its shape, strength, and appearance.

At Smile Design, root canal treatment is performed by endodontists—dentists who specialize in diagnosing and treating issues inside the tooth. With their advanced training and experience, endodontic specialists use precision tools and techniques to ensure the best possible outcome, helping you keep your natural smile intact for years to come.

What Is a Tooth Extraction?

Tooth extraction is the complete removal of a damaged tooth from its socket in the jawbone. It’s often recommended when a tooth is too damaged to be repaired. In some cases, extractions are also performed to address overcrowding, impacted wisdom teeth, or to prevent the spread of infection to other areas of the mouth.

While removing a problematic tooth can bring relief and prevent further complications, it also creates a space that may need to be filled. Depending on the location of the tooth and your long-term oral health goals, your dentist may recommend a replacement option such as a dental implant, a fixed bridge, or a removable denture. These solutions help maintain proper bite alignment, prevent neighboring teeth from shifting, and support the aesthetics of your smile.

Tooth extraction is generally considered a last resort when saving the tooth is no longer viable. It’s highly recommended in cases involving a severely decayed tooth or broken teeth that cannot be restored. It’s also common for impacted or infected wisdom teeth and for situations where infection threatens surrounding tissue or bone. Your dentist will help determine if this option is the most appropriate based on your specific condition and overall dental health.

Pros and Cons: Root Canal

Choosing a root canal can have many benefits, especially when the goal is to preserve your natural smile. It allows you to keep your natural tooth, which helps maintain the alignment and function of your bite. Retaining your original tooth also reduces stress on adjacent teeth, which might otherwise shift or wear unevenly if the tooth were removed.

A root canal also supports long-term oral health. Once treated and sealed, the tooth can continue to function just like any other, allowing you to chew, speak, and smile with confidence. With a properly placed dental crown, the tooth can be just as durable as it was before infection set in.

Root canals do have some drawbacks, though. The procedure is typically more time-intensive than an extraction, often requiring one or more appointments. It also tends to be more expensive upfront, especially if a specialist (i.e., an endodontist) is involved and a crown is needed. In some rare cases, the initial treatment may not fully eliminate the infection, leading to the need for retreatment or additional care.

Likewise, root canals might not be recommended if the tooth is too structurally compromised—such as when the damage extends below the gumline or the bone supporting the tooth has deteriorated. In those situations, a tooth extraction and replacement may be a more practical long-term solution.

Pros and Cons: Tooth Extraction

Compared to a root canal, extractions are generally simpler, quicker, and less expensive upfront, making them a practical option in many cases. One of the key benefits is immediate relief: removing the problematic tooth eliminates the source of pain and infection, often bringing fast comfort to patients in distress.

That said, extraction does come with its own set of challenges. An extracted tooth can change the way your bite functions, especially if the missing space isn’t restored with a dental implant, bridge, or denture. Over time, surrounding teeth may drift into the gap, leading to misalignment or jaw discomfort.

There’s also a risk of complications like dry socket: a painful condition where the protective blood clot is dislodged from the extraction site. There is also an eventual need for replacement options, which can add to the long-term cost and complexity. So considering the cost of an extraction on its own without also considering the cost of an implant, bridge, or removable denture might not give the full picture.

Patients can request a tooth extraction rather than a root canal, but your dentist will assess whether it’s the most appropriate choice for your situation. While extraction may seem simpler in the short term, it’s essential to consider the future impact on your oral health, including the need for tooth replacement and the potential effects on your bite and jawbone health. Your provider will help you understand the risks and benefits so you can make an informed decision.

Understanding Pain and Recovery

You may have heard anecdotes or references to the painfulness of root canals, but modern dentistry has made both these and tooth extractions far more manageable than many patients expect.

Both procedures begin with local anesthesia to completely numb the treatment area, ensuring you don’t feel pain during the process itself. Afterward, over-the-counter pain relievers like ibuprofen or acetaminophen are typically sufficient for managing discomfort, though your dentist may prescribe something stronger if needed.

Root Canals

Recovery experiences differ depending on the procedure. After a root canal, most patients experience mild soreness or sensitivity around the treated tooth for a few days. Since the tooth structure remains intact, there’s minimal disruption to surrounding tissues. Your dentist will place a crown to protect the tooth, and it’s important to avoid chewing on that side until the crown is fully set. Practicing good oral hygiene and avoiding sticky or hard foods can help ensure the crown stays in place and the tooth heals well.

Tooth Extractions

Tooth extraction recovery, on the other hand, often involves a slightly longer healing period. The body needs time to form a blood clot at the extraction site, which protects the bone and nerves underneath. It’s essential to avoid smoking, drinking through a straw, or spitting forcefully for a few days to prevent dry socket. You can help ease discomfort and reduce swelling during the healing process by using ice packs and keeping your head elevated. Your dentist or oral surgeon will provide you with a complete list of aftercare instructions after the tooth is removed.

Common tips for faster healing after either procedure include:

• Stick to soft, cool foods for the first couple of days.
• Avoid strenuous activity for at least 24 hours.
• Gently rinse with warm salt water to keep the area clean (as recommended by your dentist).
• Maintain excellent oral hygiene without disturbing the treatment site.

How Painful Is a Root Canal Procedure?

Thanks to local anesthesia and modern techniques, root canal procedures are no more painful than getting a standard dental filling. While you may feel pressure or mild soreness afterward, significant pain during the procedure is rare. In fact, most patients report feeling immediate relief from the discomfort caused by the infection or inflammation. According to the American Association of Endodontists, patients who undergo root canals are six times more likely to describe it as painless than are patients who have had extractions.

Comparing Costs and Long-Term Benefits

At first glance, tooth extraction is typically less expensive. The procedure itself is relatively straightforward and doesn’t require specialized equipment or follow-up dental restorations. However, the overall expense can rise significantly if you choose to replace the missing tooth later on, with options like dental implants, bridges, or dentures adding much of the total cost.

Root canal therapy, on the other hand, tends to have a higher upfront price tag. This is especially true when followed by the placement of a dental crown. But while the initial investment is greater, preserving your natural tooth can be more cost-effective in the long run. Keeping the tooth intact maintains the structure of your bite, eliminates the need for prosthetics, and helps prevent future dental complications that can arise from missing teeth.

It’s also important to consider the non-financial benefits of retaining your natural tooth—like the comfort of chewing normally, avoiding changes in facial structure, and maintaining a natural-looking smile. These long-term advantages may make a root canal a more appealing choice despite the higher initial expense.

Ultimately, your dentist will help you weigh the total costs and benefits—both immediate and long-term—so you can make a decision that aligns with your health needs and financial situation.

Schedule Your Treatment at Smile Design

Choosing between a root canal and a tooth extraction isn’t always straightforward—the choice depends on your specific dental condition, personal preferences, and long-term goals. Whichever you end up choosing, though, it’s important to take a deep breath, stay calm, and consult with a trusted dental professional for the best advice on your options.

At Smile Design Dentistry, our team is here to guide you through the decision with care, clarity, and compassion. We’ll help you weigh your options, explain each step of the process, and ensure your treatment plan supports your long-term health and well-being.

Ready to take the next step? Schedule an appointment with Smile Design Dentistry today and let us help you make the best choice for your smile.

FAQs about Root Canals and Tooth Extractions

Is It Better to Get a Root Canal or Pull a Tooth?

Whether it’s better to get a root canal or pull a tooth depends on the condition of the tooth and your overall dental health goals. A root canal is generally preferred when the tooth can be saved, as it preserves your natural bite, prevents neighboring teeth from shifting, and supports long-term oral health. However, extraction may be the best option when a tooth is too damaged to restore or when there’s widespread infection. While pulling a tooth may seem simpler or more cost-effective at first, it can lead to additional procedures and expenses down the road, especially if you plan to replace the missing tooth.

Will Pulling a Tooth Stop Nerve Pain?

Yes, pulling a tooth will typically stop nerve pain because the source of the pain—the inflamed or infected nerve inside the tooth—is completely removed along with the tooth itself. This can provide immediate relief, especially in cases of severe infection or trauma. The surrounding area may remain sore for several days as the extraction site heals, though, and post-operative discomfort is common.

How Does Tooth Extraction Relieve Dental Pain?

Tooth extraction relieves dental pain by physically removing the source of the problem. When the pulp inside a tooth becomes inflamed or infected, it can irritate the surrounding nerves and tissues, causing intense pain. By extracting the tooth, the infected tissue and associated pressure are eliminated, providing significant and often immediate relief. While some mild discomfort is expected during the healing process, this is generally manageable and short-lived compared to the ongoing pain caused by an untreated dental issue.

When Do You Need to Remove Wisdom Teeth?

Wisdom teeth removal is very common. It’s typically needed when the wisdom teeth are impacted, i.e. they don’t have enough space to emerge properly and press against other teeth, causing pain or alignment issues. The American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons estimates that about 90% of people in the U.S. have at least one impacted wisdom tooth.

Removal is also recommended if the wisdom teeth are partially erupted and difficult to clean, which increases the risk of decay, gum disease, or infection. In some cases, even fully erupted wisdom teeth may be extracted if they contribute to crowding or repeated dental problems. Your dentist or oral surgeon will typically recommend removal during your late teens or early twenties, when the roots are less developed and the recovery is easier.